Local News

Shaw University files official complaint, chancellor says students racially profiled on bus

Shaw University leaders on Monday announced they filed an official complaint with the U.S. Department of Justice after students' belongings were searched during an Oct. 5 trip.

Posted Updated

By
Michael Grace
, WRAL multimedia journalist & Joe Fisher, WRAL reporter
SPARTANBURG COUNTY, S.C. — Shaw University leaders on Monday announced they filed an official complaint with the U.S. Department of Justice after students' belongings were searched during an Oct. 5 trip.
Body camera video from October shows the traffic stop in Spartanburg County, South Carolina. The charter bus was transporting 18 students to a conference in Atlanta.

Dillard said one deputy boarded the bus on Oct. 5 and asked the driver where he was headed. Multiple sheriff deputies and a drug-sniffing dog searched the suitcases of the students and staff located in the luggage racks beneath the bus after the driver consented to the luggage compartment being searched.

Nothing was found.

Deputies said they initiated the stop because the driver was swerving. The driver was issued a warning ticket for improper lane use.

Dr. Paulette Dillard, Shaw's president, said, "It begs the question whether every vehicle that is stopped for a lane violation is also searched by dogs for drugs. And if not, what is the probable cause that makes that determination? Who gets searched and why?"

The complaint states a deputy boarded the bus, blocking the exit, and informed the Hispanic driver the bus was "swerving real bad within the lanes and bumping the yellow line."

The deputy asked the driver about their destination and the ages of the students, who were all Black. The officer asked the students if they "had anything up underneath the bus or anything that's not supposed to be there."

The deputy searched and found a box of donuts and allergy medication. Nothing illegal was found.

The Spartanburg and Cherokee County sheriffs declined to comment on Shaw's new complaint. 
But last month, the deputies involved denied claims of discrimination, pointing out the bus had tinted windows and they had no way to see who was inside.

"The real issue is why and how a minor traffic violation immediately turned into a drug search," said Dillard.

Deputies used a drug-sniffing dog that hit on one bag. But the complaint accuses deputies of searching several others, without students’ consent.

Legal experts WRAL News spoke with said the deputies' actions were uncalled for. They wanted more to be done to find out if the stop was racially motivated.

“The additional bags they opened were green and purple and blue. They were not the original bag. This was a continued search to find contraband. They did not find anything except for the donuts and prescription allergy medication," said Dan Blue, an attorney who wants the Department of Justice to take a closer look at how many searches stem from minor traffic offenses – and to analyze any racial disparities that might exist.

Spartanburg County Sheriff Chuck Wright stated in a press conference the deputies were concerned the bus driver was falling asleep, and that's why the driver was pulled over. He said the bus was searched with dogs because his deputies frequently seize drugs trafficked on Greyhound buses along that stretch of Interstate 85.

"The harmful effects of eroding individual rights under the pretext of law and order are real – and they are rampant all over the country," Dillard said on Monday. "But especially in this particular area in South Carolina, which has been called out previously for inequitable and discriminatory patterns of practice for disproportionate excessive searches and seizures of Black people without probable cause."

Dillard released a written statement immediately following the traffic stop, writing, "In a word, I am outraged. This behavior of targeting Black students is unacceptable and will not be ignored nor tolerated. Had the students been white, I doubt this detention and search would have occurred."

In the complaint, Shaw University requests an investigation into the search of the students and an investigation of the Spartanburg County and Cherokee County Sheriff’s Offices "for civil rights violations.”

Key areas of concern highlighted in the complaint include:

  1. Search and seizure under the pretext of an alleged lane violation
  2. Violation of the passengers’ reasonable expectation
Shaw University's student body president Mariah Williams reacted to the incident, saying, “These situations have the ability to erode public trust in established institutions that are supposed to protect and serve everyone equally.”

Dillard said she's sorry the students had to go through the experience, saying, "We are still reminded in this country, for some people, even being innocent is not enough.”

Last month, five members of congress also asked the Department of Justice to get involved by conducting a pattern-of-practice investigation.

So far, the DOJ has not responded.

 Credits 

Copyright 2024 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.